Argonne Lab (Dept. of Energy) Sued for Reverse Discrimination (updated 07-22-02)
|
The Argonne National Laboratory is staffed by 400 Department of Energy employees and is
located near Chicago, Illinois. It is a nuclear research facility. DOE
employee John Kasprowicz and six other workers at Argonne National Laboratory have filed a
reverse discrimination lawsuit in federal court against Argonne and the Department of
Energy. According to the Sun-Times, they are suing for back pay, job promotions and
$300,000 each for damages. The case may go to trial later this year (2002). |
QUOTE:
"[DOE's] problem, according to a federal lawsuit filed by Kasprowicz and six others,
was that they were white men, and that supervisors, eager to promote minorities, froze
them out in an effort to make them go away."
-- Chicago Sun-Times |
| See also DOE Minority Statistics,
below. |
|
The lawsuit against DOE charges
the following:
- Managers at Argonne received annual "super
bonuses" of $10,000 to $20,000 (on top of their $120,000 salaries) for hiring and
promoting women and minorities over white males. Argonne calls this "meeting or
exceeding diversity goals".
- 26 of 29 promotions at Argonne went to minorities
and women -- and only 3 went to white males -- between 1989 and 1993. (Government
attorneys who have been fighting the suit for the past 5 years said that at least 1 of the
26 minorities was more qualified than the whites who were passed over!)
- In order to make room for meeting federal hiring
quotas for minorities, dozens of highly qualified white male engineers, scientists and
other career employees were transferred to a "white male dinosaur" office with
the euphemistic official title "Safety and Technical Services Division (STS)".
There they received few or even no work assignments for years on end.
Argonnes hope was that the "dinosaurs" would quit or retire. According to
the Chicago Sun-Times, one manager even made it a habit to stop by the
"dinosaur" office periodically to say "'When are you going to retire, old
fellow?' or, 'What are you still doing around here?' "
- When the affected white male workers complained of
this treatment, they were retaliated against. Argonne management forced 35 other employees
to sign a petition in which they were required to indicate their support of Argonnes
discriminatory actions against the "white male dinosaurs".
| ARGONNE NEWS: As Reported by the
Washington Times on Monday July 22, 2002 |
Top
 |
TITLE: Lawsuit
cites 'superbonuses' for minority hiring as racist
|
"A Hispanic supervisor hired mostly Hispanic women to meet Department of Energy
diversity goals and discriminated against whites, a civil rights lawsuit claims.
"While project manager Anibal Taboas was staffing Chicago's Argonne National Lab with
minorities, the lawsuit claims, a group of 44 employees mostly white men
were sent to a new division created in 1995, where they were given minimal work and no
training for the rest of their careers."
According to the Times, the official title of the new "dinosaur" division was
the "Safety and Technical Services Division (STS)". |
| QUOTE: Department of
Energy spokesperson, Mr. Brian Quirke: "To my dismay, those $10,000 superbonuses [for
meeting racial quotas] lasted only three years." -- as reported by the
Washington Times |
| See also DOE Minority Statistics,
below. |
|
The Times reports that "[plaintiff John Kasprowicz] said STS exists primarily to
phase out non-minority employees. Once there, his workload "diminished to the point
of nothing," and he took a part-time job selling shoes at a Chicago Marshall Field's
store to relieve his boredom. STS employees believed they were targeted for elimination
under reduction in force policies.
"The department's nickname, even among supervisors, was
'the rif-ing pool,'" Mr. Kasprowicz said. "They made no secret they wanted us to
retire."
The Washington Times reports that the strategy has apparently been effective: the
STS (rif-ing pool) office started with 47 "dinosaurs" and so far 29 have quit or
retired in frustration. Today there are only 18 employees remaining in the STS
office.
The Times story continues: "According to seven men who filed a federal lawsuit
against former Energy Secretary Frederico F. Pena in Chicago, project manager Anibal
Taboas and others received $10,000 "superbonuses" for hiring, training and
promoting minorities. From 1989 to 1993, the suit claims, 26 out of 29 of Mr. Taboas' new
hires were non-whites."
One of the plaintiffs, Tom Balamut, as reported by the Washington Times, said that
"Mr. Taboas is "a racist and a discriminator who received substantial
bonuses." The lawsuit also alleges that Mr. Taboas sexually harassed female
staff and punished those women who complained.
The Times also reports that plaintiff John Kasprowicz alleges that Mr. Taboas "gave
[minorities] preferential training opportunities [after hiring them] so on paper they
quickly became the most qualified candidates for promotion."
The Times reports that plaintiff Kasprowicz had to send copies of
his time sheets to the Department of Energy's inspector general showing he was being paid
over $90,000 a year to do almost nothing besides checking his e-mail, at which point he
was finally transferred in 2001 to a job assignment with some actual work.
According to the lawsuit, which was originally filed in 1997,
Kasprowicz, Balamut, and the other 5 plaintiffs are suing for back pay, promotions and
$300,000 each in damages. Their case is expected to go to trial by the end of 2002.
The Washington Times reports that a Department of Energy spokesperson, Mr. Quirke, said
that DOE's diversity goals "have never been quotas". While the
"diversity bonuses" have been reduced to only $2,000 to $3,000 today, Mr. Quirke
said "We have goals to hire, train and promote minorities. To
my dismay, those $10,000 superbonuses lasted only three years."
[Emphasis added.]
(Excerpted from the Sean
Salai story titled "Lawsuit cites 'superbonuses' for minority hiring as racist"
which appeared in the Washington Times on Monday July 22, 2002)
Last known link to the Washington Times story:
http://www.washtimes.com/national/20020722-83124410.htm
| ARGONNE NEWS: As Reported by the Chicago
Sun-Times on Sunday July 14, 2002 |
Top
 |
TITLE: Ready
to work, but nothing to do all day
"John Kasprowicz went to his job as a geologist at Argonne National Laboratory every
day for nearly two years and did nothing.
"When he asked his bosses at the U.S. Department of Energy for something to do to
justify his $95,000-plus paycheck, they told him something would come along.
"But for 22 months, nothing did--that is, he says, until he sent copies of his time
sheets showing he was doing nothing all day to the DOE inspector general's office in
Washington, D.C.
"When the inspectors started making inquiries, Kasprowicz, 46, was transferred to a
different department, where he was given work.
"Some of his colleagues weren't so lucky.
According to the Sun-Times, Kasprowicz "was told by a boss that it was unlikely he'd
be promoted because he did not meet diversity goals. This was despite outstanding
performance ratings Kasprowicz had posted every year.
"At the same time, the lawsuit claims, women and minorities with less experience were
being promoted.
|
"The situation decayed further, the lawsuit charges, when Kasprowicz and several
colleagues filed complaints with their office's equal opportunity officer. Many of those
who filed complaints, according to the suit, were retaliated against by being included in
the transfer to the new division, where work was scarce.
"The suit alleges that managers yelled at workers who complained, urged other workers
to ostracize those who complained, and that 35 workers were pressured to sign a petition
upholding management's actions. |
| QUOTE:
"We are proud of the fact that we have been able to recruit, train and promote
minorities and women in our organization." -- DOE spokesman Brian Quirke, as reported
in the Sun-Times |
| See also DOE Minority Statistics,
below. |
|
"At the same time, according to the suit, the manager of this "dead end"
division, [Justin] Zamirowski, denied these employees training and travel opportunities
and up-to-date equipment.
"[One affected employee, Frederick Wysk], an officer of a national engineering
society, was told he couldn't take time off to go to a professional meeting, even though
the society was picking up the tab. "This was when I was sitting there doing
nothing," Wysk said.
"It's a Catch-22," Kasprowicz said. "They say you need training to get
promoted, but then they don't give you a chance to get the training."
"In 1995, Kasprowicz and about 44 other employees, mostly white men, were transferred
to a newly formed division at Argonne, which he said turned out to be a bureaucratic limbo
in which more than half of them weren't given any significant new work.
"They stick you in a place where you're going to waste away, and sooner or later you
leave," Kasprowicz said. "This was the process they used to eliminate us."
(Excerpted from the Art
Golab story titled "Ready to work, but nothing to do all day" which appeared in
the Chicago Sun-Times on Sunday, July 14, 2002)
Last known link to the Chicago Sun-Times story:
http://www.suntimes.com/output/news/cst-nws-argonne14.html
Over / Under Representation of Minorities at Energy
Dept.
Oct. 1, 1999 to Sept. 31, 2000 |

 |
|
| |
(A)
% in Relevant Civilian Labor Force (RCLF)
(affirmative action target) |
(B)
% in Federal Workforce (FW)
(actual % employed by DOE) |
(C)
Difference between target (col A) and actual (col B) |
(D)
Rate of over (under) hiring selected minority groups by DOE |
| Blacks |
6.8% |
11.4% |
+4.6% |
+67.6%
DOE hired 67.6% more blacks
than their proportion in the civilian labor force |
| Hispanics |
5.2% |
5.3% |
+0.1% |
+1.9%
DOE hired 1.9% more Hispanics
than their proportion in the civilian labor force |
| Asian
Pacific Islanders |
2.9% |
4.1% |
+1.2% |
+41.4%
DOE hired 41.4% more Asian
Pacific Islanders than their proportion in the civilian labor force |
| Native
American |
0.5% |
1.4% |
+0.9% |
+180.0%
DOE hired 180% more Native
Americans than their proportion in the civilian labor force |
| Women |
44.7% |
38.1% |
-6.6% |
-- |
| |
Note
1 |
Note
1 |
Note
2 |
Note
3 |
| Note 1 -- Source: OPM "Annual Report to Congress;
Federal Equal Opportunity Recruitment Program October 1, 1999 - September 30, 2000 [FY
2000]. Current link to full OPM report: http://adversity.net/fed_stats/OPM/opmreport_1999-2000.pdf Note 2 -- Computation: Col
(B) - Col (A) = Col (C)
Note 3 -- Computation:
[Col (C) / Col (A)] X 100 = Col (D) |
END of Dept. of Energy News Page |